Sunnyside Sliced - Mentone

Forget the standard suburban takeaway. Pizza purists are crowning this Mentone joint as Melbourne’s absolute apex for proper New York-style slices. Massive, foldable, and sporting that essential crisp undercarriage. The Grandma pie? A thick, airy Sicilian dream loaded with rich tomato and cheese. Slice aficionados routinely direct newcomers straight to the Garlic Magic—ideally dunked in ranch—or the hot honey-drenched pepperoni. Expect a buzzing, standing-room-only energy at the front counter, while out back, a sprawling, dog-friendly beer garden keeps the weekend crowd dialed in. Sure, you’re dropping a few extra bucks per slice, and peak hours require patience, but the wildly welcoming family service and colossal portions make it a non-negotiable stop. Grab a truffle mushroom slice, pair it with an ice-cold Arnold Palmer, and enjoy the hustle.